About Business
For professional Car Repair care in Staten Island, NY, Staten Island, look no further than Preferred Auto Body & Repair. Their team excels at delivering top-tier results for Auto body shop, Auto parts store, Auto restoration service and related Car Repair needs. Their customer-centric approach has earned them a 4.7/5 rating based on 93 pieces of feedback. They have become an integral part of the Staten Island, NY community, known for their dedication to excellence in the local Car Repair sector. For those looking for the best Car Repair experience in Staten Island, Preferred Auto Body & Repair is ready to assist with your next project or repair.
Google Reviews
Amanda Cerrotta
★★★★★
3 months ago
Came to Anthony as per a recommendation of John the car wash owner on amboy road and clarke. I stopped to see what he thought of the damage done to my car by someone in a parking lot at SIU hospital and he didn’t hesitate at all. Told me right away go see Anthony at preferred auto! BOY am I glad I did!! Within a few minutes he had a plan in mind and started the process of removing the scratch without needing a new paint job. The following day I went back for the dent removal process which really left me in awe!! Anthony then buffed the area again before I left. WOW what a nice guy and good businessman. Other places were quoting me over 1500 across 4 days to fix the dent and then repaint 3- 4 times bc of the white color of my car. I was miserable until I walked into Preferred Auto. It was my first time there and I couldn’t recommend this place and Anthony more!! He even touched up my rim that had some paint missing from accidentally hitting a curb. No judgement either!! The best, honest, courteous and all around great experience. the first two pics are before. ... the third is after Anthony buffed the scratch out and then the last pictures are no dent no scratch My car was only a month old so while these pictures may not seem so bad to you I was so angry since I had just purchased it a month ago. Thank you Anthony!!!
Elina Gerts
★★★★★
3 months ago
I was referred to Anthony at Preferred Auto Body after my car was damaged, and I’m so grateful I was. He clearly explained the entire repair process and immediately put me at ease, assuring me that he could take care of everything. He even arranged a rental car for me and I was picked up directly from the shop. Throughout the repair, Anthony kept me updated on the progress, which really helped ease my anxiety. When I picked up my car, I was amazed—it looked flawless. I genuinely forgot which side had been damaged. The dents were gone, the doors were perfectly painted, the tires were shiny, and the whole car was freshly washed. It felt like I was driving away in a brand new vehicle. I couldn’t be more thankful for the service, professionalism, and genuine care Anthony provided. His team did an incredible job. Highly recommend!
Ernie Jackson
★★★★★
Edited a month ago
Get your car body work done here!!! PERIOD!! They hooked my Dodge Charger up! *Update!* This 2026 Blizzard never had a chance with the paint on this car. Preferred Auto Body put the absolute right stuff on it. I also want to mention they did put the custom racing stripes back on the Dodge Charger. Best place ever!
Jabril Wright
★★★★★
2 months ago
I am thrilled with the work done by Preferred Auto Body. Working with Anthony was a great experience; he kept me fully updated every step of the way. My car was returned to me in amazing condition, which is a testament to the skill of Anthony and his crew. Would recommend in a heartbeat
Mary Elizabeth
★★★★★
4 months ago
Anthony and his team went beyond and above expectations. They were supportive in every way when dealing with the insurance company and the rental company. They made the whole process as easy as possible. Car came back looking wonderful and perfect condition. We will always use them in the future.
sophia frankovich
★★★★★
4 months ago
I recently took my car to Preffered Auto Body & Repair after a fender bender, and I cannot recommend them highly enough. From start to finish, the entire process was seamless, professional, and entirely stress-free. Anthony was incredibly knowledgeable and walked me through the process step by step. They exceeded all my expectations, and I wouldn't hesitate to use them again. Thank you to the whole team for making a tough situation easy!
Joseph Cuomo
★★★★★
3 weeks ago
Anthony is an amazing help. Everything was taken care of with precision and care. Car looks brand new . Highly recommend!
Angela T
★★★★★
5 months ago
Wonderful experience, reliable and fast work. Anthony, the owner is a genuine, kind, honest person who delivers on the timeframe he quotes. Everyone that works here is great. Getting into an accident isn’t a pleasant experience but preferred made it less stressful. I’m so glad I chose them. Highly recommend.
Omar J
★★★★★
5 years ago
Anthony and his crew are the best at what they do. I dropped of my top case to get painted to match my bike and they perfected it from taking it apart, painting it, and putting it back together. It looks like it came from factory. I also had them do certain things on my 19 vette and they mastered that as well. Any body work or paint, Anthony is my guy to go to. Thank you Anthony and your crew.
dana decicco
★★★★★
2 years ago
This place was awesome. Anthony took care of my car basically over night. I needed to replace two pieces on my passenger side of my suburu. Came in, ordered the parts, fixed the very next day. They were courteous and the prices were extremely fair. Thank you so much. I definitely recommend this place.
Jenny Leung
★★★★★
5 years ago
Best place to go to, Anthony will definitely take care of your vehicle. Restoring it brand new, my bmw went from a heap of rust to brand new looking vehicle/ he took care of my fender and bumper. i love the restoration and replacement of the bumper. the restoration of the little scratches of the rocks hitting my car on the highway is barely noticeable. the feeling of the car of the brand new clear coat is amazing it looks like i bought my car recently. he will help you out completely 100%. A friend recommended me to him and angel's auto glass also recommended me to him. Angel told me he will take care of me. Anthony did. thank you Anthony, i will definitely come back to you for anymore issues. Even though he takes a while but its worth the wait.
Victor Espinoza
★★★★★
8 months ago
These guys were so amazing to us. The day that we got in a very bad car accident. They really took their time to calm us down. Explain things to us. Let us know what our options were. I have honestly never dealt with an Auto repair shop that hold itself to such a high standard. I would recommend these guys any day of the week and twice on Sunday.
Valene fonseca
★★★★★
a year ago
Best Auto body shop on Staten Island! Anthony and his staff were AMAZING. Excellent bodywork! Truly recommend this place for the best work & service . I am very happy with the job they did on my car. Looks as good as new. I would highly recommend to all.
omar diaz
★★★★★
4 months ago
Took my there to do some work they did and excellent job i got my car back like new thank you Anthony
donny pagano
★★★★★
8 months ago
I’ve used Preferred for several repairs and some cosmetic work—Anthony and his team always do a great job. Professional, reliable, and easy to work with. Highly recommend.
James Pipitone
★★★★★
a year ago
I had a fantastic experience with Preferred Auto Body. Anthony and their team were incredibly professional and efficient. They even accommodated my crazy schedule, making the entire process seamless. From start to finish, they provided exceptional service and did a thorough job. I highly recommend them for anyone in need of work on your vehicle.
Paul Casale
★★★★★
9 months ago
Amazing shop. The work is always clean, professional, and done right the first time. You can tell they take real pride in what they do. Super easy to work with and always honest wouldn’t take my car anywhere else.
Breanna Mitchell-Baptiste
★★★★★
a year ago
I would recommend this shop to snot and everyone! Anthony is amazing and makes you feel like family. I came here to fix the whole front end of my car including fender, headlights, and bumper after a collision and my car came back looking amazing. He even got me an uber to enterprise to get a rental through my insurance. I passed by a second time after going to a Geico ship to fix my car after I got hit and he pointed out places where Geico made mistakes I went back to the Geico shop and they fixed everything the way I asked. I seemed I know what I was talking about because the advice I was given. I will continue to come to this shop my car is in there again and I just know it will come back amazing and beautiful.
THE MAG
★★★★★
5 years ago
I took a chance on Preferred a couple of months ago and was very pleased with the work that was done. Anthony and his guys were very professional and friendly. Anthony was very helpful in the whole process and made the experience of getting my vehicle fixed, easier than i thought it would be. He explained everything that was going on and helped a lot in dealing with the insurance company. He kept me up to date with the insurance company and how the job was going. The whole process went smooth and the shop got the repair job done within a timely manner. The crew did a great job on the repair and it looked perfect. I highly recommend this shop to anyone needing auto body repair on Staten. Thank you Anthony and Preferred for your work on my vehicle.
James Stack
★★★★★
2 years ago
Let me start off by saying that I have lots of experience in regard to autobody shops.With that being said, I am a fairly ruthlessly honest in my reviews with ZERO BIAS. I will start off by saying that I called Anthony, the owner/operator of this family business, in a pinch. I happen to damage a rim on an extremely expensive vehicle on vacation (I live in Florida) I was borrowing and needed it to be fixed with very short notice ( 24 hrs). I called a couple of other shops, but they quoted me three times the amount on average for repair and minimum 3 days to do it. Luckily, I stumbled across preferred auto body, and I couldn’t have been happier with the results. Anthony was kind, knowledgeable, and Extremely professional. A true master of his craft, but most importantly he was honest and trustworthy. If you’re looking for an autobody shop in Staten Island, Give your business to this guy. Not only will you get a phenomenal Finished product, you will get treated with respect and with fairness. Not only did he charge less than his competitors. He also completed the job faster than his competitors. That’s something I have never experienced before. From South Florida I say Thanks again, Anthony!
