Conveniently located in Staten Island, NY, Preferred Supreme has established a strong presence in the Car Repair market. They have specialized expertise in Auto repair shop, Car inspection station, Tire shop, making them a top-choice Car Repair specialist in Staten Island. Backed by 50 satisfied customers, they currently hold a prestigious 4.5/5 star status on our platform. They take pride in serving the diverse needs of Staten Island, NY residents, offering personalized Car Repair solutions that make a difference. Whether it's a routine check or a complex Car Repair task, Preferred Supreme is the go-to destination for quality and service in Staten Island, NY.
Map is ready to load
Click the button below to
display the interactive map.
This company does not care for the safety of their customers. They have unqualified people attempting to fix cars and over charging customers for work they can't deliver.
Matthew Nicholls
★☆☆☆☆
7 years ago
Terrible work and terrible customer service. Replaced brand new car parts claiming that they were defective and needed to be replaced and it would solve the issue. Parts were replaced with no change in condition of the car. Was then told there was no guarantee the parts would fix it.
Steven Tornquistif nj OP h i.p.o
★★★★★
5 months ago
Friendly fast service
Maria Cristino
★★★★★
8 months ago
Very honest, affordable and reliable.
Tricia Sawchuk
★★★★★
4 years ago
Lovely holiday work dinner! Service is great. Our server Fred was amazing.! Highly Recommend...!
Bert Gall
★★★★★
2 years ago
When you need a auto repair and inspection nice to know honest people and a very clean shop highly recommend
Christine Marie
★★★★★
5 years ago
Been going here for years honesty is the best policy and Steve is wonderful and Charlie is great they know how to treat customers they are friendly great service reasonable prices clean place I bring all my cars here and I know Steve’s father for I hate to say it 30 plus years wonderful people they are
Steve Venito
★★★★★
7 years ago
Responding back to Jaclyn Grimaldi post , Customer has not been at this repair facility since 2016. When she was at this location in 2016 it was for a NYS Inspection and wiper blades. Customer was never at this location since that day. If there is a problem with the pricing from 2016, please bring in your bill and we can review it.
Meghan Dones
★★★★★
6 years ago
The guys here are very professional and give fair prices. They take very good care of their customer's cars. Trustworthy and reliable.
Kristina “AceOfSpades” Acevedo
★★★★★
5 years ago
This shop is the best! These guys do fast and efficient work, super convenient to the train if you needed to drop it off for any reason, and their hospitality is off the charts!! Would definitely recommend!!
John Chirico
★★★★★
2 years ago
WHEN IT COMES TO LAWYERS AND TOP MECHANICS THEY ARE THE HARDEST TO FIND..... BUT I CAN HELP WITH ALL AUTOMOTIVE NEEDS..... WITH THIS NEIGHBORHOOD REPAIR SHOP....I HAVE USED THEM FOR YEARS AND THEY ALWAYS DO EXCELLENT WORK AND FULLY EXPLAIN EVERYTHING....I WOULD GIVE 10 STARS IF IT WAS ALLOWED
Curlene DMV Food & Lifestyle
★★★★★
2 years ago
Super quick had my first inspection on new car done there. They were so nice definitely will go back
William G
★★★★★
2 years ago
This is the best place for an inspection… I’ve been taking my last 2 leases here… 5 stars very nice and friendly crew of guys and they have you in and out
Steve Venito
★★★★★
a year ago
I recommend this shop very highly the owner manager Steve jr is one of most honorable men I've ever used I send all my cars there highly recommend this shop
Brittney Geisinger
★★★★★
7 years ago
Came into the shop with my 2006 bmw that was running rough and had a check engine light. The shop checked the car out and said it had a random misfire. After doing the work that was suggested, the car has been running like new since. These guys really saved my car! Very thankful for the smart and friendly staff.
Miss Marie
★★★★★
2 years ago
This service station has been in Eltingville fir as long as I can remember. Customer service is excellent. Honest. Trustworthy. Timely service. Fair prices. A place I trust to service my car. Keep up the great work!
Brian Blischke
★★★★★
a year ago
Honest and trustworthy. Friendly staff. Do high quality work. Will get you in same day if possible. Been going to their garages for work for over 20 years.
Dan H
★★★★★
a year ago
Honest service. My car was making a sound last Sunday and I went to one of the few spots on the island that was open and I was told a list of things wrong with my car. It would have taken him a full day and a half to install everything so I decided to tell him I’ll come back another day Unfortunately the sound got pretty bad today (Saturday) so I went to the closest spot which lead me to Preferred Supreme. They literally showed me that my pads were worn out and it was the cause of the sound. Everything else the previous mechanic said was ok. This was one of the moments that made me happy I got a second opinion. Quick fix (for what my car needed obviously) and I drove away with plenty of left over cash in my pocket to treat myself to some food down the street. As a business owner myself who just want to provide good and honest service to my customers, I’m happy there are still people out there who also do the same.
Medina Sukalic
★★★★★
a year ago
While grabbing breakfast before work my car decided to not start. I was having trouble with my battery. I was told by one of the girls at the breakfast spot that there was a mechanic next door. I walked over in a panic praying that they would be able to help. I have to say such amazing guys. They walked over to the spot my car was parked and got the battery to work. He drove it to his shop and told me I needed a new battery. They had my car fixed in perfect time so I can get to work. Thank you so much for your help. I’ll definitely keep you guys in mind for any future work on my car.
Andrew Park
★★★★★
6 months ago
Just got off the phone with Stephen, and I feel like I finally found a mechanic who truly understands what I need for my cars. He patiently walked me through how to deal with the brake issues I’m having with my BMW and even advised me not to waste money on things that can’t really be fixed because they’re part of the issue. I honestly wish I could give this place more stars than the system allows. Stephen and Preferred Supreme really rock! This will definitely be my go-to place for all my cars.
Visitor Reviews
No reviews yet. Be the
first to review this business!
★☆☆☆☆ 
