About Business
McCormick Quality Tires and Lube is a leading Car Repair specialist serving the Fort Collins, CO, Fort Collins area. They provide a wide variety of solutions, including Tire shop, Brake shop, Oil change service, and other Car Repair tasks. Boasting a solid 5.0/5 rating from 390 verified reviews, their reputation precedes them. As a locally-owned business in Fort Collins, CO, they are deeply committed to providing honest and reliable Car Repair support to their neighbors. If you are in need of Car Repair assistance, we invite you to reach out to them today or visit their location in Fort Collins, CO.
Google Reviews
Ben Werling
★★★★★
a month ago
I blew a tire on college and horsetooth today. Had to pull into a parking lot quickly. I couldn’t change my tire out because I didn’t have the right size socket for my oversized lug nuts. I was in a very tough spot. Like a godsend McCormick was right there. The friendly staff were very concerned about my situation. Justin was on it like an old friend. He grabbed an impact, we swapped my spare, and jgave me a quick rundown on what was going on based on the wear on my tires. He gave me a reasonable quote on fixing the problem. He wouldn’t take a dime for helping me in the moment. Very appreciative of the good people there at McCormick tire and lube. I will be a dedicated customer at this establishment. Thanks again Justin.
Clay Nash
★★★★★
2 months ago
If you are looking for a mechanic you can actually trust, look no further than McCormick Quality Tires and Lube. I recently took my Mercedes in initially to get a second opinion, but was blown away by their professionalism and honesty. They are incredibly thorough and took the time to explain exactly what my car needed and why. I specifically appreciated their transparency. They provided a clear breakdown of recommended services based on my current mileage versus what was actually necessary based on their physical inspection. There were no "surprise" fees or high-pressure sales tactics; everything was upfront and fair. A few highlights of the experience: Transparent Pricing: I knew the cost before the service was completed. Loaner Vehicle: They provided a loaner car, and a shuttle service, which made the entire process stress-free and didn't disrupt my work day. Excellent Service: The staff is genuinely friendly and treats you like a neighbor, not just a repair order. It’s rare to find a shop that balances technical expertise with such high-level customer care. I’ll definitely be bringing my vehicle back to McCormick for all future services. Highly recommended!
Kara Grosse
★★★★★
a month ago
Love these guys! Always super helpful and reasonably priced. They helped me patch my tire when Discount Tire said they were too old and tried to sell me new ones. Caleb always does great work on my tires!
Oliver James
★★★★★
2 months ago
McCormicks is amazing! Did great on my car and really cared. Fixed my transmission linkage for free just because they saw it was loose!! Also fixed my belt squeak fast and were very helpful with telling me all of the things I need to replace!
Larry Kim
★★★★★
4 months ago
We moved to the area recently and found this nearby tire shop after we discovered a slow tire pressure leak. Even though it was near closing time, Matt fit us in expeditiously. Matt is very professional, upfront, and friendly. I waited in their comfy waiting room with TV & refreshments where you can see into the garage through big clean windows. I noticed how impressively clean the garage floor and orderly the equipment is laid out. Upon finishing the quick tire plug job, he showed us the small nail that caused our slow leak. In the end he didn’t charge us for this “outside the tire” plug repair. Wow! This kind of honesty and professionalism will result in us looking to these folks for our next tire and lube needs. Thanks!
Rich Jasch
★★★★★
4 months ago
My experience today at McCormick was amazing. Today, on Veterans Day, they offered FREE oil changes to veterans. Completely free —I wish I could have paid for something, honestly. Their generosity and wanting to take care of veterans really made me feel appreciated. Needless to say, they will now be my go-to provider whenever I need car care.
Lisa Larson
★★★★★
a year ago
While traveling from St. Louis on a 6-state road trip to the West, we noticed some issues with our brakes at Yellowstone. We stayed the following night in Fort Collins and went to McCormick Tires and Lube on Manhattan Avenue the next morning. They worked us in to their busy schedule and even provided a loaner car for us! They were so efficient and thorough, including a comprehensive safety check, at a very fair price. Being a bit delayed by a herd of elk to pick up our vehicle before closing, they arranged for us to leave the loaner on their lot and pick up our van. Arriving 15 minutes after closing, Alissa and Jason were still there, awaiting our return. Without hesitation, we highly recommend McCormick’s!!! PS. From a traveling woman’s point of view…their restroom was the best! 😊 Mike and Lisa Larson O’Fallon, Missouri
Mayank mate
★★★★★
5 months ago
Went here because I noticed a slow leak in one of my tires. They fit me into their busy schedule and had a quick turnaround of the fix. A very professional and polite customer service. I highly recommend them.
Nicole Kalstein
★★★★★
4 months ago
McCormick was able to replace our tires immediately and quickly, and gave us a really thorough breakdown of everything to help plan for future work on the car. Marty was so helpful and straightforward. Will definitely be returning for future repairs and work on the car!
harold smith
★★★★★
5 months ago
McCormick Tires is a good place for prompt, polite and inexpensive help with tires. I made an appointment to check out a tire problem and they resolved the matter within 15 minutes, and added air to my tires at no charge. I will definitely go there again when I need assistance with tires.
Tobias Grey
★★★★★
a month ago
They were extremely communicative throughout the whole process, not to mention got things done quickly. Also provided a free shuttle. Wesley did great work.
Renee Hanna
★★★★★
7 months ago
This is a great place to get your car serviced. The people are very friendly and knowledgeable. I was happy with the cost of my car repairs and how quickly the work was completed. My son is a McCormick repeat customer and I plan to be also. I highly recommend them. How nice to find a place you can trust to do your car repairs well, get the work done quickly and not have to pay a fortune when the work is done.
aaron miller
★★★★★
a month ago
Wes did a great job with my jeep. They worked with me and my budget. Highly recommend McCormick.
Hannah Sellnow
★★★★★
6 months ago
Can’t say enough good things about this shop! They get you in quick (especially when you’re having a problem), they are straightforward and honest and take the time to explain the services they are recommending, and if you don’t actually need a service they don’t do it! Jason, Marty, and Alyssa are all so kind and great communicators. And the mechanics do a stellar job. Highly recommend!
Evan Elkins
★★★★★
4 months ago
They were so helpful repairing a tire leak caused by a nail. Got us in fast, made sure we were good to go. Feel confident with the repair. Not trying to sell us anything. Trustworthy and reliable.
Heather Greenwell
★★★★★
7 months ago
In from out of state to purchase a used vehicle for my college student to use. Jason was incredibly nice & immediately helpful when I reached out about doing a vehicle inspection for me. He was very thorough and informative, plus it was done at no charge. All information was given to me directly, not to the dealership. My son will be coming here for service in the future!
Andrew Headrick
★★★★★
7 months ago
Very quick to offer me assistance with a damaged tire. Honored the warranty and replaced it with a new tire free of charge. Offered me a free loaner vehicle over the weekend until the work was completed on Monday. They were concerned that my I might need alignment work but after evaluation they were honest and said it's not something I need to do right away but just to keep an eye on it. I very much appreciate the honest and integrity at McCormick.
Siglinde Peetz
★★★★★
7 months ago
10/10 service. We had a nail in our tire, and after quickly announcing our arrival per phone, they made sure to squeeze us in as soon as we got there. Very friendly, helpful and generous people, who resolved our problem quickly. Very transparent and professional throughout the process! Thanks for your kindness!
Billy Richard
★★★★★
6 months ago
Very impressed with McCormick. Marty and the gang took very good care of me- found some work to be done during an oil change then completed that work in a very timely manner. The free shuttle is an excellent perk. McCormick's is an independently owned, local business that operates with professionalism and integrity, a rare and beautiful thing.
Marc
★★★★★
6 months ago
I can’t recommend the team at McCormick highly enough! Jason and Marty are knowledgeable, straightforward, and absolutely committed to doing right by their customers. My car had a manufacturing quirk that made a routine service unusually complicated—and expensive. Every dealership from here to Denver either refused to help or quoted sky-high prices. Instead of shrugging it off, the McCormick team dug in, researched a solution, and pulled it off—saving me over $1,000 in the process. I won’t be taking my car anywhere else, and honestly, neither should you.
